Lost Colony Brewery and Cafe Menu

Eat

Lamb Stew
$9.00
Braised lamb, potatoes, carrots, and onions in a savory stew, typically includes celery and parsnips for added depth.
Guinness Stew
$9.00
Slow-braised beef, carrots, celery, and onions simmered in a rich Guinness stout gravy.
Dublin Lawyer
$15.00
Sautéed lobster in a rich whiskey cream sauce, typically includes mushrooms, onions, and served with a garlic toast.
Dublin Coddle
$13.00
Slow-cooked sausages, bacon, potatoes, and onions in a savory broth, inspired by traditional Irish comfort food.
Bangers & Mash
$16.00
Irish sausages with mashed potatoes, caramelized onions, and brown gravy.
Shepherd's Pie
$18.00
Ground beef, carrots, peas, and onions in a rich brown gravy, topped with mashed potatoes and baked until golden brown.
Cottage Pie
$18.00
Ground beef, onions, carrots, peas, and celery, topped with mashed potatoes and cheddar cheese, baked until golden.
The Full Irish
$18.00
Eggs, bacon, sausage, black and white pudding, beans, grilled tomato, home fries, and toast.
Bailey's Cheesecake
$9.00
Classic cheesecake infused with Irish cream, featuring a smooth and creamy texture on a buttery graham cracker crust.

Drink

Harp
$6.75
A traditional American lager, known for its smooth taste and balanced flavor.
Irish Flag
$9.00
This drink often includes layers of green crème de menthe, white Irish cream, and orange liqueur, representing the colors of the Irish flag.
Green Tea Shot
$8.00
A green tea shot typically includes Jameson whiskey, peach schnapps, sour mix, and a splash of Sprite.

Quantity

Wings
$3.75
Buffalo, Teriyaki, BBQ, Thai Chili, Jerk, Parmesan Garlic. Optional Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing. Special requests available.

Cheeseburger Special

Cheeseburger Special
$12.00
Cheeseburger with choice of Beef, Lamb, Wild Game, or Impossible patty. Cheese options include American, Cheddar, Gouda, Swiss, and Pepper Jack. Available temperatures: Rare to Well Done.

Platters

Boatswain's Plate
$14.00
An assortment of fried seafood including fish fillets, shrimp, scallops, and clam strips.
First Mate's Plate
$20.00
Hand-battered cod fillets, juicy chicken tenders, fried shrimp, and french fries.

Snacks + Starters

Loaded Guinness Chips
$12.00
A heaping plate of french-fried "chips" loaded with Guinness beer cheese + chopped bacon, and served with a side of Hidden Valley Ranch.
Scotch Egg
$13.00
Scotch Eggs are served soft boiled with a runny yolk, wrapped in Cheshire breakfast sausage and bread crumbs, then gently deep-fried until crispy outside while maintaining a moist centre and runny yolk. Consumer Advisory: Items contains ingredients that may be served raw or undercooked. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
London Pub Pretzel
$12.00
A soft, warm, giant-sized pub pretzel, baked + salted, then served with brown mustard, yellow mustard, and our famous Guinness beer cheese.
Tavern Wings
$16.00
Ten assorted jumbo chicken drumettes + flappers tossed in your selection of sauce, served with celery spears + your choice of Hidden Valley Ranch or Chunky Blue Cheese.
Kill Devil Spiced Deviled Eggs
$8.00
Deviled eggs with a spiced filling, typically featuring a blend of mustard, mayonnaise, and spices.
Scottish Shrimp Chowder
$6.00
Creamy chowder with tender shrimp, potatoes, and often includes bacon and leeks.

Salad + Stew

English Garden Salad
$10.00
A hand-picked selection of fresh local + regional garden vegetables served over a bed of mixed greens with your choice of Green Goddess or Hidden Valley Ranch.
Guinness Stew
$9.00
Tender beef chunks, hearty potatoes, and carrots simmered in a rich Guinness broth.

Tavern Specialties

Fish + Chips
$23.00
Golden battered ribbonfish with crispy fries. Classic pairing.
Shrimp + Chips
$23.00
Breaded shrimp served alongside chips, typically accompanied by tartar sauce and a side of coleslaw.
Oysters + Chips
$24.00
Crispy fried oysters paired with golden fries, served with tangy coleslaw and a lemon wedge.
Goujons + Chips
$16.00
Goujons paired with crispy chips. Choice of dipping sauces: ranch, BBQ, or a mix. Option for extra sauce available.
Crab Cake Entree
$36.00
Two golden brown crab cakes accompanied by creamy mashed potatoes and a medley of sautéed vegetables, garnished with a lemon wedge and fresh herbs.
Bangers + Mash
$17.00
Grilled sausages served over creamy mashed potatoes, typically includes onion gravy.
Shepherd's Pie
$18.00
Ground beef and mixed vegetables in a savory gravy, traditionally topped with a layer of mashed potatoes and baked until the top is slightly crisped.
Cottage Pie
$17.00
Ground beef, mixed vegetables like peas and carrots, typically includes onions and celery, topped with mashed potatoes and baked until golden.
Impossible Pie
$17.00
An impossible pie, a unique twist on traditional tavern fare, typically includes a savory blend of vegetables and a meat substitute, baked together in a pie crust.
Pork Knuckle
$24.00
Slow-cooked pork knuckle, typically served with braising jus, caramelized onions, and roasted root vegetables.
BBQ Thigh Special
$15.00
Grilled chicken thighs in tangy bbq sauce, typically served with coleslaw and pickles.
NEW YEAR'S DAY
$28.00
Slow-cooked corned beef, potatoes, carrots, and cabbage.
Harvest Pie
$19.00
A hearty mix of seasonal vegetables and lentils in a rich vegetable herb gravy, topped with a chive-whipped potato crust.

Burgers

American Wagyu Burger
$16.00
American Wagyu beef, choice of temp from rare to well done, served on a toasted bun.
Irish Whiskey Burger
$18.00
topped with whiskey-infused BBQ sauce, choice of meat temp from rare to well done, served on a toasted bun.
Welsh Lamb Burger
$17.00
Juicy Welsh lamb patty, customizable meat temperature from rare to well done, served in a soft bun.
Virginia Dare Burger
$16.00
Plant-Based Impossible Burger loaded with hummus, spring mix, and sliced mild jalapenos!

Sandwiches

"Manteo's Finest" Chicken Sandwich
$15.00
Manteo's Finest Chicken Sandwich typically includes a specially prepared chicken breast, accompanied by select toppings and sauces that highlight its quality, served on a freshly baked bun.
Fried Fish Toastie
$16.00
A fried fish toastie typically consists of a crispy, breaded fish fillet served on toasted bread with tartar sauce and a blend of select garnishes.
Barbecue Sandwich
$14.00
Tender pulled pork smothered in a rich barbecue sauce, typically includes coleslaw, served on a soft bun.
Crab Cake Sandwich
$21.00
A crab cake sandwich typically includes a Maryland-style crab cake on a brioche bun, accompanied by lettuce and tomato, often served with a remoulade sauce.

Kids Menu

Kid Fish + Chips
$8.00
Battered fish fillet served with crispy chips, typically accompanied by tartar sauce for dipping.
Kid Shrimp + Chips
$8.00
Breaded shrimp paired with crispy chips, typically accompanied by a tangy tartar sauce for dipping.
Kid Grilled Cheese
$8.00
Grilled cheese sandwich prepared with American cheese nestled between slices of white bread.
Kid Burger
$8.00
A kid burger typically includes a single beef patty and American cheese, served on a soft bun.
Kid Banger + Mash
$8.00
Pork sausage served with a side of mashed potatoes, typically includes a gravy topping.
Kid Chicken
$8.00

Sides

Basket Of Chips
$4.00
Thinly sliced potatoes, fried and typically includes a seasoning blend to enhance their taste, served in a basket.
Side Of Mash
$4.00
Potatoes mashed with milk and butter, seasoned to enhance their creamy texture.
Side Of Teriyaki Broccoli
$4.00
Broccoli florets glazed with a teriyaki sauce that typically includes soy sauce, mirin, and a hint of sesame.
Cinnamon Carrots
$4.00
Carrots seasoned with cinnamon, offering a sweet and slightly spiced side dish.
Side Of Cole Slaw
$4.00
Crisp cabbage and carrot slaw in a creamy dressing
Side Salad
$8.00
Fresh Green Salad: A Crisp, Refreshing Side Dish
Slice Of Soda Bread
$1.00
A single serving of soda bread, typically including a soft, dense texture and a slightly sweet flavor.
Side Of Gravy
$1.00
A side of gravy typically consists of a smooth, thick sauce made from the juices of cooked meats and thickened with flour.
Pickled Egg
$2.00
Pickled eggs with four flavor options: curry, sweet beet, jalapeño, and Old Bay.
Pickled Egg Flight
$4.00
Hard-boiled eggs pickled in a variety of house brines, offering a range of tangy and savory flavors.
Wagyu Patty
$6.00
Grilled Wagyu beef patty, typically includes a rich, juicy flavor and is perfect for adding to any main dish.
Chicken Cutlet
$5.00
A chicken cutlet, breaded and fried, typically accompanied by a selection of condiments for added flavor.
Shrimp Skewer
$9.00
Skewered shrimp, typically seasoned and grilled.
Crab Cake
$13.00
Succulent crab blended with spices, pan-seared to golden perfection.
Fish Filet
$9.00
Hand-battered fried fish filet, typically includes a seasoned crust.
Side Of Bacon
$1.00
Crispy strips of smoked pork bacon, typically served as a classic side.
Side Of Mushy Peas
$4.00
A side of peas softened through cooking and typically seasoned, offering a simple yet traditional complement.

Sweet Endings

Bailey's Irish Cheesecake
$9.00
Creamy cheesecake topped with whipped cream, drizzled with caramel and chocolate sauce.
Sticky Toffee Pudding
$9.00
Sticky toffee pudding typically includes a moist date-infused cake smothered in a rich toffee sauce, often accompanied by a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Scoop Of Ice Cream
$2.00
A single scoop of ice cream, often featuring a rich and creamy texture. Vanilla is a common flavor, but options may vary.

Lost Colony Brewery and Cafe offers a hearty and diverse menu that captures the essence of classic pub fare with a delightful twist. From rich, savory stews to mouth-watering burgers and seafood, there's something for every palate.

For those craving comfort food, the Lamb Stew and Guinness Stew are perfect choices, both brimming with tender meat and rich, flavorful broth. The Dublin Lawyer and Dublin Coddle bring a traditional Irish touch, with a satisfying mix of ingredients that transport you straight to the heart of Dublin. If you’re in the mood for something more substantial, the Bangers & Mash is a timeless favorite that never disappoints.

If you’re looking for something to snack on or share, the Loaded Guinness Chips and Scotch Egg are unbeatable. The Tavern Wings are a must-try, paired perfectly with a cold drink, while the Kill Devil Spiced Deviled Eggs offer a unique kick for those who love bold flavors. For a lighter bite, the English Garden Salad is fresh and crisp, while the Guinness Stew makes for a savory starter.

When it comes to entrees, the Fish & Chips, Shrimp & Chips, and Oysters & Chips are highlights, delivering perfectly fried seafood paired with golden, crispy fries. For something more indulgent, the Crab Cake Entree is a standout, while the Goujons & Chips offer a playful take on the classic.

For a burger fix, Lost Colony’s American Wagyu Burger is as juicy as it gets, or try the Irish Whiskey Burger for a smoky twist. The Welsh Lamb Burger and Virginia Dare Burger provide a delicious, rich alternative. Sandwiches are also a treat, with options like the Manteo’s Finest Chicken Sandwich and the crispy Fried Fish Toastie.

Don’t forget to finish off your meal with one of the tempting Sweet Endings like the decadent Bailey’s Irish Cheesecake or the comforting Sticky Toffee Pudding. Whether you're grabbing a bite for lunch or settling in for a relaxing dinner, Lost Colony Brewery and Cafe has a menu that promises to delight.